PetScoredIndependent dog food reviews

Earthborn Holistic · Dry dog food · Captured May 15, 2026

Primitive Natural

Protein content is excellent and all-life-stages certification adds nutritional credibility. The formula is dense and ingredient-rich, but not ideal for dogs with common food sensitivities.

All life stagesKibblePartially verified

Methodology Dog Food Rubric v1.0. Score reconstructed from rule events; see the trail below for sources and rule citations.

Strengths

  1. Low sensitivity risk 9.0 / 10Few of the most-named adverse-reaction trigger ingredients high on the label.
  2. Crude protein 38%High-protein bag on the guaranteed analysis panel.
  3. AAFCO all-life-stages adequacyCovers growth and maintenance — useful for multi-life-stage households.

Watch-outs

  1. Common triggers on the labelSkip if your dog avoids chicken, turkey, egg. We surface this regardless of sub-score.
  2. Nutrition Fit 4.0 / 10AAFCO adequacy, dry-matter protein, or feeding-trial evidence is partial.
  3. Partially verified source confidenceSome label or pricing fields rely on retailer-mediated capture rather than the manufacturer source. See evidence notes below.

Data status

Partially verified

Some primary-source fields are verified; unresolved fields remain visible.

Captured
May 15, 2026

Launch readiness

Source-capture hold.

This page is missing the packet or source record needed for beta QA.

Attach product source and verification packet records before promotion.

Lane
Source capture
Packet
missing
Product source
missing

Brand Trust scoring

Brand Trust record missing.

A Brand Trust signal record has not been attached yet. The product keeps its seed Brand Trust value until source-backed signals exist.

Record status
missing
Score path
Seed score still in use
Unknown signals
11
Conflicts
0
Brand sources
0

Buyer read

What should you take away?

Dog food rubric
Needs a closer source and label read.

For Primitive Natural, the main watch-outs are: this source record has not captured a verified AAFCO adequacy statement yet; the estimated cost per calorie is high compared with similar foods; some label-transparency fields, like country or facility details, are not captured in this record yet; brand-level evidence needs more source support. This is an evidence read, not a medical recommendation.

4.0
Nutrition FitAAFCO fit, calories, and dry matter protein/fat ranges.
6.0
Brand TrustWSAVA-style signals, recall mapping, and source confidence.
6.0
Ingredient ClarityNamed sources and label specificity.
9.0
Sensitivity RiskPopulation-level common allergen exposure.
6.0
ValueEstimated price per 1,000 kcal within category.

Score math

How PetScored got there.

Expand to see the rule-by-rule trail. Useful for checking the rubric; not required to make a buying decision.

dog-food-v1.0-label-events
Nutrition Fit4.0
30% of total score
7 scoring rule(s)0 context item(s)

Nutrition Fit is reconstructed from deterministic dog-food v1 rules using the currently available fixture fields.

AAFCO statement matches declared life stageA verified AAFCO adequacy statement earns points only when it matches the declared life stage.
Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for All Life Stages, including growth of large size dogs (70 lbs. or more as an adult).+3.0A
Feeding trials substantiate adequacyFeeding-trial language receives additional credit because it is stronger evidence than formulated-to-meet language.
Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for All Life Stages, including growth of large size dogs (70 lbs. or more as an adult).0.0A
Protein dry matter basis in rangeProtein is compared on dry matter basis against the growth/all life stages range of 22.5-35%.
42.2%0.0A
Fat dry matter basis in rangeFat is compared on dry matter basis against the growth/all life stages range of 8.5-22%.
22.2%0.0A
Calcium and phosphorus listedThis can earn credit once the nutrition panel stores calcium and phosphorus fields from a verified source.
not captured in v0 fixture0.0B
Calorie statement presentA calorie statement is needed for value, feeding-cost, and cross-format comparison work.
445 kcal/cup+1.0A
Large-breed puppy statementThis rule is not applicable unless the product is marketed for large-breed puppies.
not applicable0.0A
Brand Trust6.0
25% of total score
1 scoring rule(s)2 context item(s)seed in use

Brand Trust is still using the seed subscore while source signals are captured, reviewed, or blocked by conflict.

Brand Trust signal record missingThe prototype seed score remains in use until a Brand Trust signal record is attached.
not capturedcontextSeed
Brand Trust seed subscorePrototype score imported from the seed fixture. This keeps the public page auditable while verified rule events replace seed values.
6.0 / 10+6.0Seed
Source confidence visibleConfidence is shown beside the score so prototype, single-source, verified, stale, and conflict records are not treated the same.
Partially verifiedcontextSeed
Ingredient Clarity6.0
15% of total score
8 scoring rule(s)0 context item(s)

Ingredient Clarity is reconstructed from named-source and label-specificity rules.

Animal protein sources named in top 10Named species such as chicken meal or salmon count as clearer than generic terms such as meat meal or poultry by-product meal.
turkey meal | chicken meal | chicken fat | eggs+3.0B
Fat sources named in top 10Named fats, such as chicken fat or salmon oil, are clearer than generic animal fat.
chicken fat+2.0B
Grain sources are specificSpecific grains such as rice, barley, oatmeal, or sorghum earn clarity credit. Generic grain terms do not.
no grain source detected+1.0B
Preservatives explicitly namedExplicit preservative language earns clarity credit because the label tells readers what is preserving the fat or formula.
not explicitly detected0.0A
Country of manufacture statedThis can earn credit once the product source record stores a verified made-in or country-of-manufacture statement.
not captured in v0 fixture0.0C
Manufacturer identifiableThis can earn credit once the source record identifies the manufacturer from a verified product page or label.
not captured in v0 fixture0.0C
Co-packer or facility disclosedThis can earn credit once the product or brand source record publicly discloses the facility or co-packer.
not captured in v0 fixture0.0C
Ingredient splitting high on labelRelated starch or pulse ingredients high on the label are flagged for transparency. This is not treated as proof of harm.
not detected0.0C
Sensitivity Risk9.0
15% of total score
9 scoring rule(s)0 context item(s)

Sensitivity Risk is reconstructed from common allergen exposure patterns in the ingredient list.

Sensitivity baselineSensitivity Risk starts at 10 and adjusts for common exposure patterns. It is not a prediction for an individual dog.
10 / 10 before ingredient exposure adjustments+10.0A
Beef or beef-derived ingredient in top 5Beef exposure in the top five ingredients lowers the score because beef is commonly reported in canine food-reaction studies.
turkey meal | chicken meal | sweet potatoes | potatoes | peas0.0A
Dairy ingredient anywhereDairy exposure is counted anywhere on the label because even lower-position ingredients may matter for sensitive dogs.
turkey meal | chicken meal | sweet potatoes | potatoes | peas | chicken fat | whitefish meal | eggs | fruits and vegetables | natural flavor | vitamins (vitamin e supplement | niacin supplement | vitamin a supplement | calcium pantothenate | riboflavin supplement | vitamin b12 supplement | pyridoxine hydrochloride | thiamine mononitrate | vitamin d3 supplement | folic acid) | minerals (zinc proteinate | iron proteinate | copper proteinate | manganese proteinate | calcium iodate | sodium selenite)0.0A
Chicken or chicken-derived ingredient in top 5Chicken exposure in the top five ingredients lowers the score as a population-level sensitivity flag.
turkey meal | chicken meal | sweet potatoes | potatoes | peas-1.0A
Wheat or wheat gluten in top 5Wheat exposure in the top five ingredients is flagged without implying the food is unsafe.
turkey meal | chicken meal | sweet potatoes | potatoes | peas0.0A
Lamb in top 5Lamb receives a smaller exposure adjustment under the current dog-food rubric.
turkey meal | chicken meal | sweet potatoes | potatoes | peas0.0A
Multiple common sensitivity ingredients in top 5Multiple common exposure families high in the ingredient list receive an additional small adjustment.
1 of beef, dairy, chicken, wheat detected0.0B
Hydrolyzed protein primary dietHydrolyzed-protein diets can receive credit when hydrolyzed protein is a primary ingredient.
not detected0.0A
Single novel protein sourceA single novel animal protein can receive credit, but marketing claims alone do not count.
not detected0.0B
Value6.0
15% of total score
3 scoring rule(s)2 context item(s)

Value is reconstructed from package size, price, kcal density, category median, and quality caps.

Package weight parsedPackage weight is parsed from the product fixture so price can be normalized before scoring.
12.70 kgcontextC
Cost per 1,000 kcal calculatedValue uses calories rather than package price alone, because calorie density changes how long a bag lasts.
USD 1.30contextC
Category relative price bandThe base Value score comes from cost per 1,000 kcal relative to the product category median.
72% of Boutique premium dry median+8.0C
Nutrition Fit value capA low Nutrition Fit score caps Value so a cheap food is not over-rewarded when core nutrition evidence is weak.
Nutrition Fit 4.0-2.0C
Brand Trust value capA low Brand Trust score caps Value so price does not overpower weak manufacturer/source signals.
Brand Trust 6.00.0C

Ingredients

Parsed label

Turkey Meal, Chicken Meal, Sweet Potatoes, Potatoes, Peas, Chicken Fat, Whitefish Meal, Eggs, Fruits and Vegetables, Natural Flavor, Vitamins (Vitamin E Supplement, Niacin Supplement, Vitamin A Supplement, Calcium Pantothenate, Riboflavin Supplement, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Thiamine Mononitrate, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Folic Acid), Minerals (Zinc Proteinate, Iron Proteinate, Copper Proteinate, Manganese Proteinate, Calcium Iodate, Sodium Selenite)

Sensitivity flags

May matter for individual dogs

chickenturkeyeggfishlegumes

Source record

Confidence is visible by design.

Captured
May 15, 2026
Confidence
Partially verified
Sources
Earthborn Holistic official product page captured May 15, 2026
Chewy 28 lb price captured May 15, 2026
Adequacy
Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for All Life Stages, including growth of large size dogs (70 lbs. or more as an adult).

Appears in

PetScored best-for lists this food is on

All best-for lists ›

Compare to similar

Same category, within 1.2 composite

Build your own comparison ›

Where to buy

Buying Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural

Affiliate disclosure ›

Independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through these search links. Affiliate revenue does not affect the score on this page. Use whichever retailer you prefer.

FAQ

About Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural

What is the PetScored rating for Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural?

Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural scores 5.9 out of 10 on the PetScored deterministic rubric. Strongest sub-score: Sensitivity Risk. Weakest sub-score: Nutrition Fit. See the full sub-score breakdown and rule-event trail on the scorecard.

Is Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural good for dogs with food sensitivities?

Skip this food if your dog avoids chicken, turkey, egg, fish. These are common adverse-reaction trigger ingredients in published case series. If your dog tolerates these proteins, the sub-score reflects the population-level risk; individual dogs vary.

Is Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural AAFCO complete and balanced?

Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural carries this AAFCO adequacy statement: "Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for All Life Stages, including growth of large size dogs (70 lbs. …" The all-life-stages designation covers growth and maintenance.

What life stage is Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural for?

Per the bag, Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural is intended for All life stages (format: Kibble). Always cross-check the AAFCO statement on your actual bag, since recipes and life-stage designations can change between production runs.

How much does Earthborn Holistic Primitive Natural cost per calorie?

Captured retailer price: $69.99 for a 28 lb bag bag, at 4230 kcal/kg. PetScored Value sub-score benchmarks cost per 1,000 kcal against the category median rather than the sticker price — see the Value detail on the scorecard.